LANDMARK REVIEW
The initial responses to cold water immersion in man
Tipton (1989) | Clinical Science | Read the full study
What did they investigate?
For a long time, the dangers of cold water immersion were largely associated with hypothermia - the gradual cooling of the body's core temperature. But many people who drowned in cold water died within minutes, often close to safety. Their bodies simply hadn't had time to become severely hypothermic. So what was happening?
In this landmark scientific review, leading UK-based expert Michael Tipton brought together research on the body's immediate responses to cold water, focusing on what we now commonly call the cold shock response.
What does this review bring together?
The review examined decades of physiological research into what happens when humans are suddenly immersed in cold water. It draws on findings on breathing, heart rate, blood pressure, metabolism and the nervous system, exploring how these responses interact and why they can become dangerous. It also considered what influences the response, including water temperature, clothing, physical fitness and previous cold water exposure.
What were the key findings?
The immediate response to cold water can be dangerous long before hypothermia develops.
Rapid cooling of the skin triggers several involuntary reactions:
Breathing: An initial gasp followed by rapid, often uncontrollable breathing. This can make breathing coordination difficult and increase the risk of inhaling water.
Heart and circulation: Heart rate, blood pressure and the workload of the heart can increase sharply.
Breath-holding: The ability to hold your breath can be dramatically reduced, making unexpected submersion particularly dangerous.
These responses are generally strongest during the first seconds and minutes of immersion, before gradually subsiding.
Importantly, the review also discussed evidence that repeated cold water exposure can reduce some of these initial responses - a process known as habituation.
What does this mean for your swimming?
Being a strong swimmer doesn't necessarily protect you from the initial effects of cold water. The cold shock response can temporarily interfere with your breathing and ability to swim, even before significant body cooling occurs. This is one reason why it is important to enter cold water in a controlled manner, keeping your airway clear and allowing your breathing to settle before you start your swim (i.e. waiting until you are “swim-ready”, a key safety principle for BLUE LAB activities). And while repeated exposure can make the initial response less pronounced, it doesn't remove the other risks associated with cold water.
Why we find this interesting
This is one of the foundational publications in the science of cold water immersion. What makes it particularly important is the shift in perspective: the first danger of cold water isn't necessarily getting too cold. It's how your body reacts to the sudden cold.
The review brought together evidence that helped explain why even capable swimmers can get into difficulty almost immediately after entering cold water. It also laid out questions about cold adaptation that subsequent experiments would investigate in much greater detail.